首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
Nice people do racism too. Liberal commitment to a multi-ethnic Britain is wilting. Some very nice folk have apparently decided
Nice people do racism too. Liberal commitment to a multi-ethnic Britain is wilting. Some very nice folk have apparently decided
admin
2013-01-24
61
问题
Nice people do racism too. Liberal commitment to a multi-ethnic Britain is wilting. Some very nice folk have apparently decided that the nation’s real problem is too many immigrants of too many kinds. Faced with a daily onslaught against migrants it may be understandable to give in to populist bigotry; but it is not forgivable.
Take this, for example: "National citizenship is inherently exclusionary." So no foreigners need ever apply for naturalisation, then. And" ... public anxiety about migration ... is usually based on a rational understanding of the value of British citizenship and its~ incompatibility with over-porous borders". Straight from the lexicon of the far right. And best of all: "You can have a welfare state provided that you are a homogenous society with intensely shared values."
These are extracts from an article in the Observer, penned by the liberal intellectual Goodhart, who is just one of several liberal thinkers now vigorously making what they consider a progressive argument against immigration. It goes like this: the more diverse a society, the less likely its citizens are to share common values; the fewer common values, the weaker the support for vital institutions of social solidarity, such as the welfare state and the National Health Service.
There are perfectly good reasons to worry about how we respond to immigration, not least the downward pressure on workers’ wages; the growth of racial inequality; and the exploitation of illegals. But the answer to these problems is not genteel xenophobia, but trade union rights, backed by equality and employment law.
The xenophobes should come clean. Their argument is not about immigration at all. They are liberal Powellites; what really bothers them is race and culture. If today’s immigrants were white people from the old Commonwealth, Goodhart and his friends would say that they pose no threat because they share Anglo-Saxon values.
Unfortunately for liberal Powellites, the real history of the NHS shatters their fundamental case against diversity. The NHS is a world-beating example of the way that ethnic diversity can create social solidarity. Launched by a Welshman, built by Irish: labourers, founded on the skills of Caribbean nurses and Indian doctors, it is now being rescued by an emergency injection of Filipino nurses, refugee ancillaries and antipodean medics. And it remains 100% British.
Virtually all of our public services have depended heavily on immigrants. Powell was forced to admit as much when, as minister for health he advertised for staff in the Caribbean. His new admirers will discover that a rapidly depopulating Europe will have no choice but to embrace diversity.
For the moment, however, the liberal Powellites are gaining support in high places. Their ideas are inspired by the work of the American sociologist Putnam, a Downing Street favourite. He purports to show that dynamic, diverse communities are more fragmented than stable, monoethnic ones. But the policy wonks have forgotten that Putnam’s research was conducted in a society so marked by segregation that even black millionaires still live in gated ghettoes.
The prime minister still seems uneasy on the issue. Last week, he wavered uncertainly between backing his pro-immigration home secretary, and a defensive response to Howard’s goading that the government was in a mess on the topic.
Oddly enough, this is a place in the arena of world politics where the PM does not stand shoulder to shoulder with Bush. The Spanish-speaking former governor of Texas recently announced that he would "regularise" the status of millions of illegal Mexican immigrants who had slipped across the border to work. It’s the kind of massive amnesty that would send the Daily Express into conniptions.
Even more peculiar, the prime minister appears to be ignoring not only Blunkett but also his new best friend, the Labour mayor of London, Livingstone, and Scotland’s first minister, McConnell. London wants more immigrants to keep pace with its booming economy, Scotland wants them to boost its ageing work force..Yet the liberal Powellites still seem prepared to confront a Bush-Blunkett-Livingstone-McConnell axis, because they are scared witless by the far right. They hope that by appeasing racism, they’ll make it go away. But this is a beast with an insatiable appetite.
The French discovered that too late; the thuggish National Front is now France’s second largest party, with one in five likely to vote for them in upcoming local elections. Liberal secularists who joined in the assault on the rights of French Muslims now have to find a convincing explanation for their cowardice, which has also betrayed the freedom of expression of French Jews and Christians.
In Holland, this spinelessness has ended up as straight leftwing racism. The previously liberal Dutch establishment is now pushing an asylum policy so extreme even the Sun was moved to criticise it.
The line up that favours managed migration and diversity--Blunkett, McConnell, Livingstone, Bush and the Sun--share one quality that the PM should envy m6re than any other at present: they are all popular with the public. Maybe the government ought to pay, more heed to this focus group than the ones that see scary foreigners on every street corner.
Perhaps we should also be creating an even more progressive immigration policy, for example offering easier admission to those who will bring their skills to the depopulated regions of the north. The Americans will next year offer more work permits to IT whizzkids from India than ever before; and before the middle of the century, the world’s strongest economy will become its most ethnically diverse. Our own population is still over 92% white; we shouldn’t be duped by anxious faint-hearts into becoming an all-white backwater.
According to the passage, which of the following statements is NOT true?
选项
A、Those who dislike immigrants should admit their mistakes.
B、The UK and the US do not agree on the immigration issue.
C、The Daily Express supports Texas’s regularizing illegal immigrants.
D、Racism will not automatically come to an end if people give in to it.
答案
C
解析
第十段最后一句话应能说明选项C为正确答案:It’s the kind of massive amnesty that would send the Daily Express into conniptions(愤怒).显然,the Daily Express是不赞成Texas的做法的。其他选项所指均为作者意见(A,见第五段第一句;B,见第十段第一句;D,见第十一段末尾两句)。
转载请注明原文地址:https://www.kaotiyun.com/show/QraO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
Asubtledistinctioninthewaywomenaresingledoutbythelanguageisevidentinthewaythatthesamepersonality【M1】______
A、Greetings.B、Beingtoolong.C、Reiteratingwhat’sintheresume.D、Brilliantlanguage.A
Theyaresuperstitionsattachedtonumbers;eventhoseancientGreeksbelievedthatallnumbersandtheirmultiplehavesomemys
SurveyresultsindicatethatsmokingandalcoholandmarijuanauseincreasedamongresidentsofManhattanduringthe5-8weeksa
ThefoundersoftheRepublicviewedtheirrevolutionprimarilyinpoliticalratherthaneconomicorsocialterms.Andtheytalke
The18acenturywitnessedanewliteraryform-themodemEnglishnovel,whichcontrarytothemedievalromance,givesa______pre
Theterm"formallearning"isusedinthispapertorefertoalllearningwhichtakesplaceintheclassroom,withoutregardto
BodySystemsAbodysystemreferstoagroupoforgans,whicharepartsofthebodythatdoaspecialjob,suchastheheart,
Australialiesinthe______ofAsia.ItbelongstoOceania.
Thedeclineofcivilityandgoodmannersmaybeworryingpeoplemorethancrime,accordingtoGentilityRecalled,editedbyDigb
随机试题
甲公司为一家在深圳证券交易所上市的企业,主要从事饮料包装成套设备的研发、生产和销售。2015年度,甲公司发生的部分业务资料如下:(1)2015年2月5日,甲公司通过全国中小型企业股份转让系统以每股5元的价格购入A公司股票2000万股,取得A公司40%有
下列消费者属于一级消费者的是()
青年男性,2天来胸背部疼痛,今晨出现双下肢无力,伴二便障碍,查脐以下各种感觉障碍,双下肢肌力0级,无病理反射。最可能的诊断是
失范行为是与教育规范不相一致、不协调甚至是冲突的行为。可以划分为:目的取向型失范行为、价值取向型失范行为、情感型失范行为、传统型失范行为这四类理想类型。其中情感型失范行为,主要指为了满足生理、心理或情感上的需要而做出的失范行为。根据上述定义,下列属于情感型
(2015广西33)2013年5月,微博上______着一份百字令微情书。“不尽红笺相思意”,一时感动无数网友争相效仿。整篇文字呈菱形排列,词句婉约,文笔______,从中可以看到作者表达爱情的______。依次填入画横线部分最恰当的一项是:
论述产品如何适应国外市场条件。[河北工业大学2011国际商务硕士]
GUESSCONSULTING121MarketSt.,NewYork,NY10012J.P.Thompson,Esq.14,RueduMontBlanc1201Geneva
Readthebusinesscoverletterbelow.Inmostofthelines(41-52),thereisoneextraword.Iteitherisgrammaticallyincor
Cyberia--InternetCafesEvaPascoeridestoworkonamotorbike.Herbusinesswardrobefeaturessuchitemsasblackleggings,
李先生上个月生了一个男孩。
最新回复
(
0
)