首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
外语
The problem with the nature-nurture debate is that this is an inadequate way of understanding human freedom. Like every other or
The problem with the nature-nurture debate is that this is an inadequate way of understanding human freedom. Like every other or
admin
2011-01-08
90
问题
The problem with the nature-nurture debate is that this is an inadequate way of understanding human freedom. Like every other organism, humans are shaped by both nature and nurture. But unlike any other organism, we are also defined by our ability to transcend both, by our capacity to overcome the constraints imposed both by our genetic and our cultural heritage.
It is not that human beings have floated free of the laws of causation. It is rather that humans are not simply the passive end result of a chain of causes, whether natural or environmental. We have developed the capacity to intervene actively in both nature and culture, to shape both to our will.
To put this another way, humans, uniquely, are subjects as well as objects. We are biological beings, and under the purview of biological and physical laws. But we are also conscious beings with purpose and agency, traits the possession of which allow us to design ways of breaking the constraints of biological and physical laws.
All non-human animals are constrained by the tools that nature has bequeathed them through natural selection, and by the environmental conditions in which they find themselves. No animal is capable of asking questions or generating problems that are irrelevant to its immediate circumstances or its evolutionarily designed needs.
When a beaver builds a dam, it doesn’t ask itself why it does so, or whether there is a better way of doing it. When a swallow flies south, it doesn’t wonder why it is hotter in Africa or what would happen if it flew still further south. Humans do ask themselves these and many other kinds of questions questions that have no relevance, indeed make little sense, in the context of evolved needs and goals.
What marks out humans is our capacity to go beyond our naturally defined goals such as the need to find food, shelter or a mate and to establish human-created goals. Our evolutionary heritage certainly shapes the way that humans approach the world. But it does not limit it.
Similarly, our cultural heritage influences the ways in which we think about the world and the kinds of questions we ask of it, but it does not imprison them. If membership of a particular culture absolutely shaped our worldview, then historical change would never be possible:
If the people of medieval Europe had been totally determined by the worldview sustained by medieval European culture, it would not have been possible for that society to have become anything different. It would not have been possible, for instance, to have developed new ideas about individualism and materialism, or to have created new totals of technology and new political institutions.
Human beings are not automata who simply respond blindly to whatever culture in which they find themselves, any more than they are automata that blindly respond to their evolutionary heritage. There is a tension between the way a culture shapes individuals within its purview and the way that those individuals respond to that culture, just as there is a tension between the way natural selection shapes the way that humans think about the world and the way that humans respond to our natural heritage. This tension allows people to think critically and imaginatively, and to look beyond a particular culture’s horizons.
In the six million years since the human and chimpanzee lines first diverged on either side of Africa’s Great Rift Valley, the behaviour and lifestyles of chimpanzees have barely changed. Human behaviour and lifestyles clearly have. Humans have learned to learn from previous generations, to improve upon their work, and to establish a momentum to human life and culture that has taken us from cave art to quantum physics and to the unraveling of the genome. It is this capacity for constant innovation that distinguishes humans from all other animals.
All animals have an evolutionary past. Only humans make history. The historical, transformative quality of being human is why the so-called nature-nurture debate, while creating considerable friction, has thrown little light on what it means to be human. To understand human freedom we need to understand not so much whether we are creatures of nature or nurture, but how, despite being shaped by’ both nature and nurture, we are also able to transcend both.
A beaver builds a dam because ______.
选项
A、it imitates human behavior
B、it tries to find a better way of living
C、dam-building is relevant to its evolved needs and goals
D、a dam helps a beaver to go beyond its evolutionarily determined circumstances
答案
C
解析
根据第4、5段,其他动物受到自然选择所带来的工具和环境的束缚;没有动物能够超脱周围的环境和进化所决定的需求来做一些不相干的事情,如探索问题等。例如河狸在筑坝时,它没有问自己为什么要这样做以及是否有更好的方法。因此,选项C为正确答案。
转载请注明原文地址:https://www.kaotiyun.com/show/V3eO777K
0
专业英语八级
相关试题推荐
Intheword"unpredictable","pre-"isa______.
Norms:TypesandAcceptanceSociologistsfindthattounderstandaculture,itisveryimportanttounderstanditsnorms.Ⅰ.
TheProblemsLearnersofEnglishFaceTheproblemslearnersofEnglishfacecanbedividedintothreebroadcategories:a)
TheProblemsLearnersofEnglishFaceTheproblemslearnersofEnglishfacecanbedividedintothreebroadcategories:a)
TheProblemsLearnersofEnglishFaceTheproblemslearnersofEnglishfacecanbedividedintothreebroadcategories:a)
Inthelate1960smanypeopleinNorthAmericaturnedtheirattentiontoenvironmentalproblems,andnewsteel-and-glassskyscra
A、admiringB、respectfulC、disapprovingD、understandingC
ModesofTransportationThereareavarietyofmeansfortransportation.Usually,thechoiceoftransportationdependsonth
ModesofTransportationThereareavarietyofmeansfortransportation.Usually,thechoiceoftransportationdependsonth
A、Therewere13,000peopleneededtobemoved.B、Thehurricanecamein1988killed300people.C、Itisthelargestresortinthe
随机试题
发生下列情形的,停止发给失业救济金及其他费用,具体包括()
A.夜间阵发性呼吸困难B.突发性呼吸困难C.进行性呼吸窘迫D.活动后呼吸困难心源性水肿
《建设工程安全生产管理条例》规定,安全警示标志必须符合()标准。
某项经济资源虽能给企业带来未来经济利益,但企业不拥有其所有权,则企业不能将其视为自有资产核算。()
所有自给性服务都不属于生产范畴。()
工会在跨企业的团结权方面具有强大的力量的劳动关系的调整模式是()。
当代国际垄断的主要形式是跨国公司,当代经济生活国际化的主要承担者和体现者也是跨国公司。()
“不折腾”其实是对一个常识的______:一个正常的社会,必须______致力于增进以民主和民生为双轴的全民核心利益,必须______改善包括物质生活、精神生活、政治生活在内的公共生活,必须在安定和谐中让民众免于匮乏与恐惧。填入划横线部分最恰当的一
【S1】【S7】
Itisalwayssatisfyingtodosomethingthatnooneelse______.
最新回复
(
0
)