首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
New York City Council passed the ban on smoking in its parks and on its beaches on the principle that a nonsmoker shouldn’t have
New York City Council passed the ban on smoking in its parks and on its beaches on the principle that a nonsmoker shouldn’t have
admin
2012-07-06
75
问题
New York City Council passed the ban on smoking in its parks and on its beaches on the principle that a nonsmoker shouldn’t have to inhale even a tiny amount of secondhand smoke, whether in a bar or a Central Park meadow. But while there is a strong public-health case for banning smoking indoors, the case for banning it outdoors is much weaker — particularly when it runs the risk of a backlash that could undermine the basic goals of the antismoking movement.
True, there is evidence that being near someone smoking, even outdoors, can result in significant secondhand smoke exposure. Researchers at Stanford found that levels of tobacco smoke within three feet of a smoker outside are comparable to inside levels. But no evidence demonstrates that the duration of outdoor exposure — in places where people can move freely about — is long enough to cause substantial health damage.
But that hasn’t stopped many opponents of smoking. Citing new research, they have argued that even transient exposure to tobacco smoke can cause severe health effects like heart disease and lung cancer. For example, last year the surgeon general’s office claimed that "even brief exposure to secondhand smoke can cause cardiovascular disease and could trigger acute cardiac events, such as heart attack," and that "inhaling even the smallest amount of tobacco smoke can also damage your DNA, which can lead to cancer. "
However, the surgeon general’s statement conflates the temporary negative effects of secondhand smoke on the circulatory system, which have been shown to occur with short-term exposure, with heart disease, a process that requires repeated exposure and recurring damage to the coronary arteries. It also conflates one-time DNA damage, which occurs with any carcinogenic exposure, with cancer risk, which likewise generally requires repeated exposure.
Moreover, bans like New York’s may actually increase exposure by creating smoke-filled areas near park entrances that cannot be avoided.
To make matters worse, in trying to convince people that even transient exposure to secondhand smoke is a potentially deadly hazard, smoking opponents risk losing scientific credibility. The antismoking movement has always fought with science on its side, but New York’s ban on outdoor smoking seems to fulfill its opponents’ charge that the movement is being driven instead by an unthinking hatred of tobacco smoke. That, in turn, could jeopardize more important fronts in the antismoking fight, in particular the 21 states that still allow smoking in bars and restaurants.
A ban on outdoor smoking may provide a symbolic victory. But from a public health perspective, it’s pointless. Instead, antismoking organizations should focus on extending workplace protections, already enjoyed by millions of New Yorkers, to the 100 million Americans still denied the right to work without having to breathe in secondhand smoke. [455 words]
The author’s attitude toward the New York’s ban can be best described as______.
选项
A、enthusiastic
B、objective
C、critical
D、puzzled
答案
C
解析
本题考查作者态度。
转载请注明原文地址:https://www.kaotiyun.com/show/7Mp4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
Inthefollowingtext,somesentenceshavebeenremoved.ForQuestions41-45,choosethemostsuitableonefromthelist(A、B、C、
Cultureisthesumtotalofallthetraditions,customs,beliefs,andwaysoflifeofagivengroupofhumanbeings.Inthis(1)
Inthetwodecadesbetween1929and1949,sculptureintheUnitedStatessustainedwhatwasprobablythegreatestexpansionins
Digitalphotographyisstillnewenoughthatmostofushaveyettoformanopinionaboutit,muchless(1)_____apointofview
Digitalphotographyisstillnewenoughthatmostofushaveyettoformanopinionaboutit,muchless(1)_____apointofview
Digitalphotographyisstillnewenoughthatmostofushaveyettoformanopinionaboutit,muchless(1)_____apointofview
ItcanbeinferredfromParagraph1thatoneimportantfactorintheincreasingimportanceofeducationintheUnitedStateswas
Theexampleof"ApolloCreed"ismentionedtoshowthatTheauthor’sattitudetowardleft-handersis
Psychologistsoncebelievedthatthemotivethatcausedmentostrivetoattainhigh-levelmanagerialpositionswasthe"needfo
StephenM.Saland,chairmanoftheStateSenateEducationCommittee,isaconservativeupstateRepublican,andStevenSanders,c
随机试题
A.上直肌B下直肌C.睫状肌D.外直肌E.瞳孔括约肌调节晶状体曲度的肌
席勒把艺术分为“美的艺术”和()
氨基酸与蛋白质共有的性质是
正确的刷手范围是
骨纤维异常增殖症典型的X线表现是
《医疗废物管理条例》中所称医疗废物,是指医疗卫生机构在医疗、预防、保健及其他相关活动中产生的()
孙某以张某构成诽谤罪向某县人民法院提起自诉。县人民法院受理本案后,决定对本案适用普通程序进行审理。在张某未被羁押的情况下,该法院立案后应在下列哪个时间内宣判?()
甲公司适用所得税税率为15%,其2016年发生的交易或事项中,会计与税法处理存在差异的事项如下:①当期购入作为可供出售金融资产核算的股票投资,期末公允价值大于取得成本160万元;②收到与资产相关政府补助1600万元,税法规定将其计入当期应纳税所得额,相关资
圆柱的表面积与球的表面积之比是3:2。(1)圆柱轴截面是正方形,且其边长与球的直径相等;(2)圆柱轴截面是长方形,长与宽的比为2:1,且其长与球的直径相等。
Onereactiontoalltheconcernabouttropicaldeforestationisablankstarethatasksthequestion,"SinceIdon’tliveinthe
最新回复
(
0
)