首页
外语
计算机
考研
公务员
职业资格
财经
工程
司法
医学
专升本
自考
实用职业技能
登录
考研
Robert Trivers’s new book the Folly of Fools is a curious document — a book about deception and self-deception that is itself de
Robert Trivers’s new book the Folly of Fools is a curious document — a book about deception and self-deception that is itself de
admin
2014-06-25
13
问题
Robert Trivers’s new book the Folly of Fools is a curious document — a book about deception and self-deception that is itself deceptive, in structure, voice and argument.
A celebrated evolutionary biologist, Trivers uses the tools of his trade to answer a basic question: Why are deception and self-deception so prevalent? Our eyes, noses, tongues, ears and skin tell us so much about the world, why is it that our brains then deny some of this information, hide it from ourselves and others? Natural selection should have rooted out such tendencies—unless they offer some evolutionary advantage.
Trivers thinks they do. Lying can obviously be helpful, keeping us out of trouble, making us seem better than we are. But our bodies are not so good at fibbing. We have "tells" an uptick in our voices, sweating palms — and as lies multiply, it becomes difficult to keep track of them. Much better, then, to first deceive ourselves, to believe the lie, so that when we present it to the world all those giveaways are gone.
Trivers offers this bit of reasoning as the basis of a "science of self-deception. " But in making his arguments, he turns away from the algebraic logic of modern evolutionary biology and opts, instead, for the approach of 19th-century romantic natural history. "The Folly of Fools" assumes the unity of all nature and seeks to comprehend it not merely by observation and reason, but also by subjective impressions, intuition and imagination. And thus Trivers ranges across biology, anthropology, history and politics to find examples of deception and self-deception in action.
Two problems arise from this arrangement. First, it is unclear for whom this book is meant. Scientists are unlikely to find the argument rigorous enough to be persuasive. But the book may not appeal to lay readers, either. Many of Trivers’s examples feel underdeveloped, and the quick jumps from one to another may give the uninitiated reader vertigo. Fewer examples, more fully developed, could have better drawn in the interested non-scientist. The second problem with his method is its breadth. The examples never gel into a coherent argument. Rather, deception comes to mean so many things that it means nothing at all: The deception that plays out between a cuckoo and the bird in whose nest it has left its eggs is not the deception that explains Japan’s refusal to come to terms with the Rape of Nanking and neither seems related to the use of misleading metaphors, another form of deception Trivers discusses.
Whatever the case, to fully understand these — and much of human life — one must turn to history, sociology, psychology and political science. Yet Trivers derides these disciplines. They are rife with self-deception, he argues, their theories not based on the robust methods of physics — where self-deception is minimized, he insists — but on a preference for poorly defined variables and a tendency to cherry-pick examples. The irony, of course, is that these are the very problems that undermine Trivers’s own book.
The author might rate the Folly of Fools as______,
选项
A、a tangled web of deception
B、a deep probe into self-deception
C、a great work with some trivial faults
D、a new perspective on psychological phenomena
答案
A
解析
本题实际考查作者态度,应综合全文信息进行解答。作者在首段就旗帜鲜明地亮出了观点,他认为特里弗斯的新书从结构、态度到观点都充满了欺骗性;然后对书中存在的问题进行了详细阐述,包括沦证方法不统一,不客观,读者定位不明确,对欺骗的定义过于宽泛以及对人文学科的错误认识等等。很明显,作者对特里弗斯的新书《傻瓜的愚蠢》持否定态度,认为这是一本“关于欺骗的欺骗性的书”,[A]选项符合作者态度。
转载请注明原文地址:https://www.kaotiyun.com/show/2TK4777K
0
考研英语一
相关试题推荐
HowdoyougettoCarnegieHall?Practice.Inagroundbreakingpaperpublishedin1993,cognitivepsychologistAndersEricssona
Innovationisawordlikedemocracy.Everyoneisinfavourofit,butdifferentpeopleattachdifferentmeaningstoit.IsEasyj
(46)In1798ThomasRobertMalthusfamouslypredictedthatshort-termgainsinlivingstandardswouldinevitablybeunderminedas
(46)In1798ThomasRobertMalthusfamouslypredictedthatshort-termgainsinlivingstandardswouldinevitablybeunderminedas
Studythefollowingphotocarefullyandwriteanessayinwhichyoushould1)describethephoto,2)interpretthemeaningofth
ItwasreportedrecentlythatonewomanfollowedactorAndyLauaroundfortenyears.Whatisyouropinionofthosewhoblindly
Ifyouwereaskedtosendonethingrepresentingyourcountrytoaninternationalexhibition,whatwouldyouchoose?Why?Uses
Thenumberofthecompaniesthatwereestablishedin2002isaboutThereasonwhyagoodbusinessplanisimportantisthatit
Achemicalplantshouldberesponsibleforthewaterpollutioninanearbyriver.WritealettertotheCityEnvironmentProtect
Thegreatchariotofsociety,whichforsolonghadrundownthegentleslopeoftradition,nowfounditselfpoweredbyaninter
随机试题
业主设备工程项目管理组织中各单位承担各自的角色,下列说法正确的有()。
某消防施工单位对某酒店的自动消防设施进行安装施工,根据现行国家标准、《火灾自动报警系统设计规范》(GB50116),下列消防设备中,可直接与火灾报警控制器连接的是()。
美国商业银行在紧急情况下向美联储申请贷款,美联储收取的利率是()。
在我国,特赦由()。
依我国《继承法》,关于遗嘱继承与法定继承的关系,正确的选项是()。
对西欧封建社会的说法不正确的是()。
下表是从某人格测验研究报告中摘录的一些数据,试结合表中提供的信息解释影响信度系数的因素。(2011年)
甲欠乙债款5万元久拖不还,乙为了逼甲还债把甲锁在自家地窖中三个月,甲称无钱可还,乙很恼火把甲打成重伤,乙的行为构成()。
A、Heshouldjustsitaround.B、Hejustneededtoliveintheirhouse.C、Hehadtomowandwaterthehouseplants.D、Hehadtotak
A、Itisessentialforbusinessinteractions.B、Itcontributestothequalityofpeople’slife.C、Peoplewantmorehigh-qualityp
最新回复
(
0
)